Paint Buying Guide

A Paint Buying Guide… what does that even mean?! Great question. Please allow us to explain.

Paint Buying GuideWe’re constantly clicking through Pinterest to find our favorite paint colors & are continuously bombarded by gorgeous paint choices within the blogosphere. And like good bloggers, we note the color and brand and keep these ideas in our “back pocket” just in case we need that perfect gray, that gorgeous navy we’ve been searching for, or even that crisp white that needs to immediately be added to our DIY to-do list. As we review our list later, we see some Benjamin Moore colors, some Sherwin Williams’ colors, some Valspar colors… and this isn’t even everything. We are instantly overwhelmed.

Where do we go to find each of these brands in order to pick up a swatch, a sample, or even a gallon of this color so we can get right to work? HELP!

meters paint converseThat’s where the Paint Buying Guide comes in. Because we really weren’t sure before, we did some research on where to buy each brand of paint and have used that information to come up with an easy reference guide to help us ALL organize where to find that perfect paint color/brand you’ve been eyeing. Are you ready to break this down?

lowes-paint-swatches-nycAs B’s dad (a professional painting contractor) explained it, each hardware store has a paint brand(s) that aligns with a “library” of paint colors (hence the swatches you can pick up). If you go to each of these stores, you will find each paint brand’s library of colors as well as the actual paint to purchase in order to get right to work. Here’s a list of places to buy paint and what brand/color library you will find at each:

At Lowe’s, you will find…Paint Guide Lowe's

Valspar // HGTV Home by Sherwin Williams // Rust-Oleum

At Home Depot, you will find…Paint Guide Menards

Behr //  Glidden // Martha Stewart // Rust-Oleum

At Ace Hardware, you will find…Paint Guide Ace

Clark + Kensington // Valspar // Amy Howard At Home (Chalk Paint)

At Menard’s, you will find…Paint Guide Menards

Pittsburgh Paints & Stains // Dutch Boy // Rust-Oleum

At Walmart, you will find…Paint Guide Walmart

Glidden // ColorPlace // Some Rust-Oleum // Some Krylon (Spray Paint)

Independent (Free Standing) Stores for PaintPaint Guide Benjamin Moore Sherwin WIlliams

Benjamin Moore // Sherwin Williams  

Easy enough right? You want Lipstick Red from Valspar, you go to Lowe’s. You want Behr’s Fine Burgundy, you go to Home Depot. But what if you want Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter but prefer to paint with Valspar Paint??

gray-paint-swatches-001Now this is where it gets a tad confusing. If you LOVE the color from Benjamin Moore but prefer or would like to save money by using Valspar paint, there’s another option for you. According to our painting expert (thanks Dad!), 99% of the time you can take the color that you love to the hardware store and they will color match that exact color using the brand you prefer (ie. you can use Valspar paint but a Benjamin Moore color). <— Mind Blown.

paint-supplies-swatches-brush-quartSo the next time you note that perfect paint color via Pinterest or the blogosphere, we hope you can reference this guide to see exactly where you go to find a sample of that color. Once you get the sample, you can either buy the gallon right there from that location or take that color swatch to the hardware store of your choice so that you can get the swatch color matched & buy the brand you prefer.

Looking for more painting posts? Here’s a list of our favorite paint colors, and here are some tips for choosing the perfect paint color. Happy painting!

Bridget and Casey Signature



  • Trisha R

    This is great and so helpful!! Thank you so much for putting this together!!

  • Thank you for sharing, Nadine!! What a great tip that Sherwin Williams will call when there is going to be a sale or new paint in stock — love this!

  • This is very helpful! We usually buy Valspar from Lowes but I think we’re finally going to try a Benjamin Moore color from Pinterest…see how this goes.

  • This is a great reference guide! Thanks so much guys for putting in the work

    • Buying paint can be confusing & overwhelming, we are glad we could help!! =)

  • Perfect timing! Our house will be finished being built in only 6-8 weeks and it’s time for us to choose paint colors. Ahhh! This blog has inspired me so much. We’re likely painting the entire first floor with Sherwin Williams’ “Passive”. Although I am digging the whole getting it for less idea 😀

    • Congrats on the new house! What an exciting time! Passive is a good color, a nice light & cool gray..with a hint of blue. Hope you love it!

    • We LOVEEEE Passive Gray by Sherwin Williams! Good luck, we’d love to see pictures!! =)